A recent post, (Western Snowpack is 137% of Normal) at Watt’s Up With That? (www.wattsupwiththat.com) raised questions in my mind about the current and future water level for Lake Powell. The post covered current snowpack in the west and the changing levels of Lake Powell. While Arizona had a very wet winter, 12 feet of snow fell in Flagstaff, the areas that contribute to Lake Powell’s inflow did not have great years. Also, since the snow stopped falling in earnest, Flagstaff has seen a significant dry spell, with lots of wind. So, how to dissect all of this?

First, let’s take a look at the season’s snowpack. Here is a chart that tells an interesting story and was shown at Watts Up With That.

Western US Snowpack 5-25-2010

Western US Snowpack 5-25-2010

The overall average is impressively positive. But, Colorado and Utah are both below average. While not as dry as some recent Flagstaff winters have been, Utah and Colorado are both below normal. For much of last winter, the snowpack above Lake Powell has been below normal. Today, the snowpack is reported as being 68% of average for this date. The total precipitation is reported as 88% of average. (Reference: http://lakepowell.water-data.com/) Again, 88% of normal isn’t terrible when considering some recent years. In 2002, the lake level pretty much fell all spring and summer.

Lake Powell Snowpack - 2007 to 2010

Lake Powell Snowpack - 2007 to 2010

This last winter has been consistent. The percent of normal snowpack has remained a 70-90% band for most of the winter. Notice how early warmth of 2007 and 2009 caused the snowpack to diminish rapidly. There is more to this story. Take a look at the departure from normal daily mean temperatures for late April and early May in Grand Junction, Colorado.

Departure from Normal Daily Mean Temperatures Late April to Early May 2010, Grand Junction, Colorado

Departure from Normal Daily Mean Temperatures Late April to Early May 2010, Grand Junction, Colorado

Like most of the Southwest, several cool storms pushed May temperatures below normal. This helps prevent the snow melt from accelerating. It also put a hiccup in the inflow rates for Lake Powell. For a while in May it looked like the spring run-off had ended early.

Lake Powell Water Levels 2010

Lake Powell Water Levels 2010

Early May water level measurements show a small plateau. Still, given the low snowpack levels for the year, this years increase in level is going to be as noticeable as the massive recoveries of 2008 and 2009. Thankfully, the water level stayed high enough this year to keep the Castle Rock cut-off open through the winter. This saves a considerable amount of gas by not having to go around to the south.

Lake Powell Water Levels - 2006-2010

Lake Powell Water Levels - 2006-2010

The post at Watts Up With That? goes on to discuss the overall lower precipitation rates in the West since last October. Yes, lower than average. While we had record breaking storms in December and January, many of the other months in the last year have been below average. Remember, the summer of 2009 was nearly a summer without a monsoon season. But, most of the West has been cooler than normal as well.

So, where will Lake Powell end up this year? I think we will see a later peak that 2007 with an increase of 15-20 feet. This will put the lake in the 3635 foot level (my official guess). Below last year and about the same as 2008. The cool temperatures have delayed the spring melt for a while. The absence of heavy precipitation late in the season prevented a big boost to snowpack from being realized. Still, the snowpack remaining is much higher than the 2007 and 2009. So, there is still time to see the water arrive at the lake.

At Wayne’s Words website (www.wayneswords.com), Wayne Gustaveson run an annual contest to guess Lake Powell’s peak water level. A survey of the guess’s posted there shows an average guess of ~3642 feet and a median guess of ~3643 feet. Knowing that none of us is as smart of all of us, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the peak level to come in at 3642-3643 feet. Wayne keeps tons of great information at his site. I highly recommend visiting it before you go to Lake Powell.

If things hold, this weekend could be the best weekend this year. The temperatures, and hopefully light winds, should make the conditions near perfect. One can hope.

Today and Friday are going to be windy, again. It doesn’t look like the cooler temperatures ushered in with previous wind storms are going to show up this time. So, high shoud stay around 70 and above. The most recent cooling caused our monthly average to drop again. Today, the monthly mean temperature stands at -2.7 degrees compared to normal.

As the wind howls, and the temperature continue below average, many are asking, “Will we ever be warm again?” Believe it or not, Saturday came in at 5 degrees above normal for the day. It was a cool day in most people minds, but the lows weren’t that low. Still, for the month we are looking probably being 1.5 to 2 degrees below normal, again. But, it did get me wondering about how we are looking from a monthly mean temperature point of view. The results are shocking! Or are they.

Here is my first chart, looking back to June of 2008. This is a chart of the departure from average for each month over a history that goes back to January 2004.

Departure from Normal (1-2004 to 4-2010) - Monthly Mean Temperatures

Departure from Normal (1-2004 to 4-2010) - Monthly Mean Temperatures

I thought a trend line might help complete the painting of a dreadful picture. The data show a clear cooling trend of amazing magnitude. The trend line shows a drop of nearly 3 degrees in the roughly 2-year time frame. If this were to continue, in 10 years we probably wouldn’t see a day above freezing all year round. Where’s Al Gore now!!!

OK, wait a minute. It has been mostly below normal since last summer. This was probably due to the North Atlantic Oscillation which was strongly and persistently negative over the last year, and the El Nino, which was supposed to die late last summer, persisted until recently. Both can have powerful effects on our weather, like combining to deliver 12 feet of snow to Flagstaff.

If you go back a little farther, we see a slightly different story.

Departure from Normal - Monthly Mean Temperatures May-2007 to April 2010

Departure from Normal - Monthly Mean Temperatures May-2007 to April 2010

One of the first things that should stand out is that I cherry-picked the data in the first graph. The departure from normal for May 2008 made the chart look less drastic. No scare factor. I wouldn’t get a grant approved or hit the mainstream media without a bunch of fear. Still the trend over this time frame is negative, and the recent spate of months with repeated below average temperatures seems significant. The trend from last fall to present still shows nicely.

I keep a running log of data off the National Weather Service’s data site. My file can be found here: Click to Download the Data. There is quite a bit of other stuff in this file. The info for this post is mostly in the “Mean” and “Sheet 5″ spreadsheets. I used Open Office for preparing the spreadsheet.

Anyway, looking back across the entire data set, yet a different story is seen.

Departure from Normal - Monthly Mean Temperatures January 2004 to April 2010

Departure from Normal - Monthly Mean Temperatures January 2004 to April 2010

The trend over the last year is still very noticeable. But, the overall trend line is positive in this view. It’s less than a fraction of a degree change over the time period and probably still as meaningless as the the other two trend lines.

I think there are a couple points to note. First, when it gets cold, it gets really cold. There are 6 data points with the departure from normal being -4 degrees or colder. There is only one data point with the departure from normal being +4 degrees or more. Second, just on a visual basis, I see two other trends. One is the warming trend from March 2005 to February 2006. It appears there was a mild La Nina during this time frame. Second is a warming trend from August-September 2006 to November 2007. During this time, it looks like a strong, persistent shift in the Pacific Decadal Oscillation to negative occurred.

So, the bottom line is that is has been cool in recent months. The Climate Prediction Center is forecasting relief. We should be baking this summer.

June - August 2010 Temperature Outloook

June - August 2010 Temperature Outloook

May 202010

Well, I spoke too soon yesterday. The weekend had been looking calm and warm. We will still have lots of sun, but the winds and cooler temperatures are on their way back. Here is the NOAA/NWS prediction for wind gusts on Saturday. Highs will be in the 60′s, but over night lows could hit the 20′s. These winds are the result of the continuing storm track to the north of Arizona with the tails of the low pressure systems dipping south.

Wind Gusts 5 pm Saturday May 22, 2010

Wind Gusts 5 pm Saturday May 22, 2010

Notice the disconnect at the Utah Border, and a roughly north-south line between Kingman and Seligman . I think this is due to different tweaks that are made to the models by local or regional offices.

My weather station showed a low of just over 30 degrees. The minimum overnight temperature reported by the National Weather Service for the airport was 31.

Morning Termpatures May 19, 2010 - National Weather Service

Morning Termpatures May 19, 2010 - National Weather Service

Going back to the probabilities for spring freezes, we that late May continues to have a high probability of temperatures below 32 degrees. So, it’s not that out of the ordinary to see temperatures in this range. For those living in Bellemont, the low was 20F.

Spring Freeze Probabilities - Flagstaff Airport

Spring Freeze Probabilities - Flagstaff Airport

The outlook continues to be more of the same. Some days sunny with highs in the mid-70′s. Some days cooler with highs struggling to hit the low 60′s and overnight lows near to below freezing. Wind on several occasions.

May 162010

I haven’t written for a while. This is mostly because I didn’t think anything interesting was going to happen. I thought the last couple weeks were going to be like May of 2009:

May 2009 - Conditions

May 2009 - Conditions

Wow, that was a beautiful month. Outside all the time, sunny skies. There was a single cool, not cold, spell where the daily temperatures struggled to hit 60. The end of the month was slightly cooler than average, but still very nice. Overall May 2009, was a whooping 5.1 degrees above normal. Nice!

Early long range outlooks echoed a similar event for this year. Here we are, currently running 2.7 degrees below normal! While we are behind on precipitation, we have had several cold storms move across and linger over the area.

May 2010- Conditions

May 2010- Conditions

One final point, we have had 0.10 inch of precipitation. May of 2009 was very wet with 2.08 inches of precipitation. Quite a difference between the two.

Where to go from here? Well, it looks like there are at least a couple more cool waves in the outlook. One is centered around Tuesday. One next weekend. Both will probably be predominately windy and cool. Then, as it has been since April, consistent warm weather is lurking beyond the 1 week horizon. It has yet to arrive.

Again? May had been looking pretty promising for temperatures and snow free. But, with a below average start to the month, and another cold spell ahead, it’s not looking up yet. The start to next week is looking chilly and wind, and there is some small chance of rain or…snow.

Early next week, high temperatures will be in the upper 40′s and low 50′s. Overnight temperatures could dip back into the 20′s.

6-10 day Temperature Outlook - Climate Prediction Center

6-10 day Temperature Outlook - Climate Prediction Center

April has been very stable with respect to temperatures since 2004. I track the monthly temperature  results since 2004 in a spreadsheet. The high, low and mean temperatures are included. For most months, across all three sets, the standard deviation is more than two degrees. April has a low temperature standard deviation of only 0.9 degrees. The high and mean temperature standard deviations are 1.99 and 1.14 degrees. All of this added up to put April’s average high(56.3F), low(26.6F) and mean(41.5F) temperatures more than 1 standard deviation below the monthly averages for each category going back to 2004.

Overall, the National Weather Service Monthly report shows the monthly mean temperature 1.5 degrees below average.  March, February and January were 1.4, 2.1 and 1.3 degrees below average. A long cold winter. Things are starting to look up. May is forecasted to be warmer than average. But, I have to say, “I’ll believe it, when I feel it.”

© 2010 Stu's Weather Suffusion WordPress theme by Sayontan Sinha
5 visitors online now
0 guests, 5 bots, 0 members
Max visitors today: 6 at 12:49 am UTC
This month: 12 at 09-04-2010 05:52 pm UTC
This year: 29 at 05-21-2010 07:33 pm UTC
All time: 29 at 05-21-2010 07:33 pm UTC